Free Shipping on Orders $100+ — Canada
Short answer: Organic lip balm is a moisturizing balm made with waxes, butters and oils instead of a petroleum base. Petroleum-based balms are common and widely used, so the choice between the two comes down to feel, scent and what you prefer to put on your skin, not one being right and the other wrong.
Key takeaways
- Organic lip balm is built on waxes, butters and oils; many conventional balms are built on petrolatum.
- Both types sit on the lips and slow moisture loss, so the difference is mostly feel and preference.
- Dermatology guidance is more concerned with irritants such as menthol, camphor and strong flavours than with the base.
- "Organic" describes how ingredients are grown, not how mild a balm is.
Knightsmen Recommends
Organic Lip Balm | Coconut Flavored
A lip balm with a light coconut flavour. Its ingredient list includes beeswax, and the product page states no parabens.
Shop Now →What is organic lip balm?
Organic lip balm is a lip balm made from waxes, butters and oils, such as beeswax, shea butter and plant oils, rather than a petroleum base. The word organic describes how the ingredients are grown and processed. It does not tell you how a balm feels or how well your lips tolerate it: Cleveland Clinic notes that natural and organic ingredients can still cause problems for some people.
If a label says organic, look for the certifier's name and the full ingredient list rather than the word alone. A short list of ingredients you recognize is easier to judge than a long one.
How does organic lip balm differ from petroleum-based lip balm?
The main difference is the base. Organic lip balms use waxes, butters and oils, while many conventional balms use petrolatum, also called petroleum jelly. Some also contain mineral oil, which is a separate petroleum-derived oil. Both kinds sit on the surface of the lips and slow moisture loss, so the difference is mostly in feel.
| Typical comparison | Waxes, butters and oils | Petrolatum-based |
|---|---|---|
| Base | Beeswax, plant butters and plant oils | Petrolatum, sometimes with mineral oil |
| Source | Bees and plants | Petroleum |
| Feel | Creamier, with a scent of its own | Smooth and slick, usually neutral in scent |
| A reason to choose it | You prefer to avoid petroleum-derived ingredients | You want a simple, widely used ointment base |
The American Academy of Dermatology lists petrolatum and white petroleum jelly among the ingredients it suggests looking for in a lip product, so choosing a waxes-and-butters balm is a matter of preference rather than a safety rule.
What should you check on a lip balm label?
Check the ingredient list for what is in the balm and for what is left out. These are the points worth a look.
- The base. Beeswax, shea butter and plant oils, or petrolatum and mineral oil. Pick the feel you prefer.
- Flavour and fragrance. The American Academy of Dermatology lists fragrance and flavourings, especially cinnamon, citrus, mint and peppermint, among the things that can irritate dry, chapped lips.
- Strong additives. Camphor, eucalyptus, menthol, phenol and salicylic acid are on the same list. A dermatologist quoted by Cleveland Clinic says phenol, menthol and salicylic acid can leave lips feeling drier.
- The certification. If a label says organic, look for the certifier's name.
If your lips burn or sting after you apply a product, stop using it.
When should you use lip balm?
Use lip balm whenever your lips feel dry, and build it into your day: in the morning, before you go outside, after eating or drinking, and before bed. Cold wind and dry air are hard on lips, and meals wear a balm off. A balm applied before bed lasts longer because you are not eating or drinking.
Keep a tube where you will use it, such as a jacket pocket, a car or a desk drawer. If you catch yourself licking your lips, reach for the balm instead: the American Academy of Dermatology says licking can worsen dryness, because lips become drier as saliva evaporates. If your lips stay dry, cracked or sore after two to three weeks of gentle care, see a doctor or dermatologist rather than adding more products.
What is in Knightsmen's organic lip balms?
We make two organic lip balms: Organic Lip Balm | Coconut Flavored and Organic Lip Balm | Vanilla Flavored. Both are handcrafted in small batches in Toronto, Canada, list beeswax among their ingredients and, according to the product pages, contain no parabens. The two ingredient tabs match apart from the flavour.
The coconut balm has a light coconut scent that is not candy-sweet, and the vanilla balm has a light, subtle vanilla. Both are compact enough to carry in a pocket. Check the ingredient tab on each product page for the full list, and browse the organic lip balm collection. For a wider buying guide, read our lip balm guide for men.
Frequently asked questions
Is lip balm necessary for men?
It is not essential, but it is useful. Men's lips are as exposed to cold, wind and dry air as anyone else's, and lips have no oil glands of their own, according to Cleveland Clinic. A basic lip balm is one of the simplest personal care habits to add, and it takes seconds to apply.
Can lip balm cause dependency?
Not in the physical sense, according to a dermatologist quoted by Cleveland Clinic, although using it can become a habit. The reapply cycle some people notice can be linked to ingredients such as phenol, menthol and salicylic acid, which can leave lips feeling drier. A simple balm without them is a sensible choice, whatever the base.
Is organic lip balm better than regular lip balm?
Not necessarily. Organic describes how ingredients are grown and processed, not how mild a balm is, and Cleveland Clinic notes that organic ingredients can still cause problems for some people. Many people choose organic lip balm because they prefer natural waxes, butters and oils and an ingredient list they can read. Choose by ingredients, flavour and how your lips feel.
How do I know if a lip balm does not suit me?
If your lips burn or sting after you apply a product, the American Academy of Dermatology says it is irritating your lips and you should stop using it. Strong flavours, fragrance and menthol are common culprits. If your lips stay dry or sore after two to three weeks of gentle care, see a doctor or dermatologist.
Sources
- Cleveland Clinic: are natural skin care products actually better for your skin?
- Cleveland Clinic: are lip balms bad for you, and could they be addictive?
- Cleveland Clinic: chapped lips, causes and prevention
- American Academy of Dermatology: dermatologists' tips for dry, chapped lips
Knightsmen Grooming products are cosmetics. This guide is general information, not medical advice. If you have a skin or scalp condition, or sudden changes in your hair, see a doctor or dermatologist.
